Reviews & Awards

Our exquisite cooking guarantees a delicious meal. Fortunately, we are not the only ones who feel that way, so here is a list of our awards and quotes from food critics.


  • Voted Best hoagie by the Valley Advantage 2009,2010,2011,2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017 and 2018.
  • Voted best hoagie/sandwich shop by Happenings Magazine 2016.
  • Voted best hoagie by the Scranton Times 2012 
  • Voted Best Cheese Steak Scranton Times 2017
  • Voted Best Cheese Steak Electric city 2017



  • The Only Place for Hoagies & Sandwiches

    by LisaSmith14

    Steve & Irene's is my favorite place to get great sandwiches at exceptional prices. I honesty don't think I can make an Italian hoagie at home for the cost of what they charge. Tons of meat, fresh bread, crisp veges! The Italian Hoagie is one of my favorites along with their hamburgers and cheesesteaks (I highly recommend the Pittsburgh Cheesesteak)

    They also have specials that they swtich out monthly. I just had their pulled pork sandwich topped with cole slaw-YUM! I had yet to order the "Saucy Dog" but someday I will try it.

    The staff is always friendly and accomodating when you call and pick up your food. Delivery is also available to the surrounding area.

    If you are anywhere near Mayfield, this is THE place to go for sandwiches. It's definitely worth the trip.

    • Pros: Excellent Food, Super Friendly Service & Great Prices
    • Cons: Not always heathy but ALWAYS delicious!






by anthonydepo

All i have to say is this place has the best hogies around well and potato pancakes.....Always fresh hot friendly service i will always order my hogies from here....prices are great as well...

  • Pros: out of this world food and service



The Best
Diner from Scranton • Matthew
The best sandwiches around. Amazing variety, great prices, a wonderful staff. This place even takes bizarre custom orders from picky customers (namely me and the Cajun chicken ranch with bacon and fried onions). This place is easily missed by most, it's a hole in the wall joint but believe me you can't find a better place to get a sub. Tons of cheesesteaks, lots of homemade recipes including pulled pork, porchetta, chicken fajita and much more. The rolls are wholesome, soft, and when toasted have a delicious crunch. Overall, after eating subs up and down the east coast, Steve & Irene's is...  a FANTASTIC little secret in a small town with the absolute best hoagies. If you haven't had a sub from haven't had a real sub yet. P.S TRY THEIR CAJUN FRIES!!!!!!!